Rich, buttery toffee in a sugar-free syrup, ready to turn an ordinary cup of coffee into something that tastes like a treat. If English Toffee was your favorite, you already know this one: Butter Toffee is the new name for the very same formula.

What you'll love

• Rich, buttery toffee flavor
• Sugar free, without the unwanted calories
• Same formula as English Toffee, now called Butter Toffee
• Versatile: coffee, tea, protein shakes, baking, oatmeal and more

How to enjoy it

Stir it into a hot latte on a chilly morning, shake it into iced coffee with a splash of cream, or drizzle a little over warm oatmeal. It's also an easy way to dress up a vanilla protein shake or a batch of homemade muffins, and it makes a cozy cup of black tea feel like dessert.

Gift it

Tuck a bottle into a coffee lover's basket with a pretty mug, or add it to a teacher, neighbor or coworker gift for a sweet little surprise this season.

Order online for shipping anywhere in the U.S., or choose free pickup at our boutique in downtown Marion, Virginia.

Shipping

• We ship within the United States. Standard flat-rate shipping is $7.95, and standard shipping is FREE on orders of $125 or more (after discounts, before taxes).
• Orders are processed and packed within 1–3 business days (Monday–Friday, excluding holidays).
• Standard delivery takes 3–7 business days after shipping, so most orders arrive within 4–10 business days of being placed.
• Orders ship via USPS, UPS, FedEx, or another qualified carrier. You'll receive a tracking email once your order ships.
• FREE local pickup is available at 201 E. Main Street, Suite 109, Marion, VA. Choose Local Pickup at checkout and wait for your ready-for-pickup notification before visiting.

Returns

• Online orders: returns must be requested and postmarked within 14 days of delivery. In-store purchases: within 14 days of purchase.
• To start a return, email hello@justbelieveboutique.com or call (276) 780-3733 with your order number.
• Items must be unworn, unwashed, and in new condition with all tags attached, and free of odors, makeup, pet hair, stains, or wear.
• Approved returns receive store credit only. Please allow 5–7 business days after we receive your return for processing.
• Final sale (not returnable): giveaways, accessories, jewelry, hats, hair accessories, beauty and skincare, perfume, drinkware, home décor, intimates, leggings, gift cards, clearance, items discounted 30% or more, and items marked “Final Sale.”
• Original shipping is nonrefundable, and return shipping is the customer's responsibility unless the item arrived damaged, defective, or incorrect.
• Damaged, defective, or wrong item? Email us within 3 days of delivery with your order number and photos.
• Exchanges: return the eligible item for store credit, then use it toward the size or color you want.

See our full Shipping Policy and Refund Policy for complete details.

What does Butter Toffee Syrup taste like?
A rich, buttery toffee flavor.

Is Butter Toffee the same as English Toffee?
Yes. Butter Toffee is the new flavor name for the same formula previously sold as English Toffee.

Does it have sugar?
No. It's sugar free and adds flavor without the unwanted calories.

How can I use it?
Add it to coffee, tea, protein shakes, baking or oatmeal.